| Platinum | Marco's Pizza |
| Gold | Godfather's Pizza |
| Silver | Orsi's Italian Bakery & Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Copp's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Casey's Carryout Pizza |
| Top Pick | Frank's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Luigi's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mama's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Valentino's |
| Top Pick | Varsity Sports Cafe & Roman Coin Pizza |