| Platinum | Abelardo's Mexican Food |
| Gold | Howard's Charro Cafe |
| Silver | Romeo's Mexican Food & Pizza |
| Bronze | La Mesa Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Guaca Maya Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | La Mesa Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Lil' Burro Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sam's Leon Mexican Food |
| Top Pick | Wild Chicken |